27 Best places to sell toys near me & online for the most cash!

We may earn a commission for purchases through links on our site, Learn more.

Share This Article:

Do you have a pile of toys that your kids have outgrown? Or maybe you’ve been collecting toys for a while now, but they’ve started to take up too much space in your home. Whatever the reason, you might wonder how and where to sell these toys. Fortunately, many options are available to you, depending on your preference.

If you want to sell your toys locally, consider taking them to a local store that buys used toys. Some toy stores or consignment shops may be interested in buying your used toys, especially if they’re in good condition. You can also check out flea markets and garage sales or even host your own yard sale to get rid of your old toys.

On the other hand, if you prefer to sell your toys online, there are many platforms to list your items for sale. Websites such as eBay, Amazon, and Facebook Marketplace are popular choices. You can also try specialized toy-selling websites like ToySwap or ToyCollector to reach a more targeted audience.

Regardless of your option, take clear and attractive photos of your toys, write a detailed description, and price them competitively to attract buyers. With a little effort, you can turn your old toys into extra cash and free up valuable storage space in your home.

Today, I’ll share the top places where you can sell toys for cash, whether nearby or online. I’ve divided them into categories to help you find the right platform more easily.

Where to sell used toys online

Here are some top websites and apps for selling your items hassle-free.

Some platforms require you to ship your items to buyers upon sale, while others facilitate in-person pickups.

However, all of these platforms provide a convenient way to sell your toys online.

1. Toycycle

Toycycle makes selling toys hassle-free with its full-service consignment. They pick up your items, sell them on your behalf, and you receive payment afterward. It’s that easy!

After your item sells, you’ll receive a payout ranging from 15% to 80% of the sale price. The percentage depends on the value of each item, with higher-value toys earning you more. You can get paid in cash or store credit or donate your earnings to charity.

2. Craigslist

Craigslist remains a top choice for selling items online, attracting a large user base. One of its perks is listing your items for sale without any fees.

Plus, there are no commissions, so you keep all your earnings. Creating a listing on Craigslist is straightforward and hassle-free.

3. Kidzen

You can sell toys on Kidzen. When your items are sold and shipped, you’ll receive payment to your PayPal or bank account. Alternatively, you can receive your earnings as store credit for future purchases on Kidzen.

4. eBay

with over 182 million shoppers, eBay is a prime platform for selling toys. The vast number of potential buyers alone makes it a valuable place to sell your items.

You can list up to 50 items for free on eBay. After that, it’s 30 cents per listing. When your items sell, eBay takes a 10% commission fee.

5. 5miles

Sell your old toys hassle-free with 5miles, a platform that doesn’t take any commission fees, meaning you keep 100% of your sales. However, listing fees may apply for certain categories.

6. OfferUp

Next up is OfferUp, a popular platform with millions of users looking to buy things, making it an excellent place to sell toys. You can sell various items, including clothing, furniture, and toys. It’s a mobile marketplace connecting local buyers and sellers, offering a quick and easy listing process. You can create a listing for your toys in under 30 seconds.

The best part is it’s free to list items for sale. LetGo, another well-known selling website, has merged with OfferUp.

7. Varage Sale

VarageSale is an online platform similar to a garage sale, where you can sell items locally. It offers various categories, including toys, making it a good option if you’re looking to sell toys in your area.

8. Mercari

Mercari is a versatile platform for selling various items, including kids’ clothes and toys. It offers specific sections for toys, collectibles, and vintage items, making it a convenient choice for selling children’s belongings.

Listing toys for sale on Mercari is free of charge. However, once your items sell, there is a 10% selling fee.

9. Shpock

With Shpock, short for “shop in your pocket,” you can easily sell various items, including toys and board games. Creating a listing on the platform is simple, and there are no fees.

10. eBid

eBid offers an extensive online marketplace where you can sell items through auctions or at fixed prices. With over 25,000 categories available, you’ll find the perfect spot for your listings.

Whether you’re into Dolls and bears or Toys and hobbies, eBid provides a platform for selling your used toys hassle-free.

Membership options cater to different seller needs. The basic Seller account is ideal for casual sellers and comes at no cost. Listing items is free with this account. When your items sell, you’ll incur a final value fee of 5%.

For those seeking more benefits, the Seller+ plan offers the option to waive the final value fee entirely. Pricing for Seller+ varies based on duration:

  • 7 Days: $1.99
  • 30 Days: $6.99
  • 90 Days: $16.99
  • 365 Days: $69.99
  • Lifetime (special offer available): $139.99

11. Bonanza

You can list a variety of toys, including die-cast models, action figures, and dolls, for free on Bonanza.

When your items sell, you’ll be charged a commission fee of 3.5%.

12. Gumtree

If you’re based in the UK and looking to sell your used toys, you might consider using Gumtree. Gumtree is a popular online classifieds platform that provides sellers with a wide range of categories for listing items. The platform offers several categories of toys, including used, outdoor, and baby and kid toys.

Gumtree is particularly popular in the UK, with a large and active user base. This makes it an excellent place to list your toys for sale. Whether you’re looking to declutter your home, sell items that your children have outgrown, or make some extra cash, Gumtree could be an excellent option for you. The platform is user-friendly and offers a range of features to make the selling process easy and efficient.

13. Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace can be an excellent platform for parents to sell their old toys, as many parents are already active on Facebook. You can find a wide variety of toys on the marketplace, including popular items from past decades like Beanie Babies, Cabbage Patch Dolls, Leap Pad, Star Wars figurines, Rubix Cube, and Easy Bake Oven, among others.

The Marketplace offers several categories of toys, such as toy vehicles, building toys, outdoor toys, doll’s houses, educational toys, stuffed toys, action figures, and board games. Moreover, Facebook charges a selling fee of 5% per shipment or a flat fee of $0.40 for shipments of $8.00 or less. So, if you have old toys lying around and want to make some extra cash, consider selling them on Facebook Marketplace.

14. Brain’s Toys

Brain’s Toys stands out from other websites because it buys unopened toys. If you have toys still in their packaging, you can get a quote from the site.

15. Bergen Pickers

Bergen Pickers buys various items, including:

  • Barbies
  • LEGO toys
  • Flash Gordon memorabilia

It’s a great spot for selling both modern and vintage toys.

Best places to sell toys near me

If you don’t want the hassle of listing items online, you might prefer selling your toys at a nearby store for instant cash.

Here are some places you can check out if you’re looking to sell toys locally.

16. Once Upon a Child

You can sell gently used toys, children’s clothes, shoes, furniture, and baby gear at a Once Upon a Child store near you.

Simply bring your items to the store, where an employee will inspect them. If you agree to their offer, you’ll get paid in cash on the spot.

Read Also:  How to track a USPS package without a tracking number (2024)

It’s recommended to call ahead to find out which items are most wanted.

17. Rogue Toys

Rogue Toys specializes in a variety of toys, including:

  • DC
  • Marvel
  • GI Joe
  • Transformers
  • Dolls

If you have any of these types of toys to sell, consider giving the store a try.

The company operates three stores, two in Las Vegas and one in Oregon. Check out their site if you’re in these areas and want to sell toys.

Simply visit your closest store, where an employee will assess the value of your items based on their condition, rarity, and demand. You’ll receive an offer, and if you agree, you’ll be paid cash right away.

For those outside of Las Vegas or Oregon, you can still sell your toys to Rogue Toys by shipping them to the company. They’ll send you payment upon receipt.

18. Children’s Orchard

Children’s Orchard gladly welcomes gently used children’s toys and clothes.

Simply bring in your items, and their buyers will assess them. You’ll receive instant cash for the items Children’s Orchard selects to sell in its store. Alternatively, you can opt for store credit to earn extra money.

19. Kid to Kid

Sell your used toys to Kid to Kid by taking them to the nearest store. Check the store’s buying hours beforehand. The process typically takes 15 to 45 minutes.

An employee will assess your items and make an offer. If you’re satisfied, you can accept it. Payment options include cash or 20% more in trade value.

20. Yard Sales

Your traditional yard sale can still be profitable, especially if you have big items or a diverse range of things to sell.

Selling your stuff is easy and convenient without the need to carry it to a store or handle shipping. If you have plenty of children’s toys to sell, a yard sale can be a great option. Additionally, you can reach customers who prefer shopping in person rather than online.

21. Consignment Shops

This place could be your best bet if you want to sell big, bulky, or a wide range of toys. Consignment shops might not offer the best pay, but they require less effort. They usually accept well-kept toys, baby items, bikes, strollers, and trendy toys.

22. Local Thrift Store

If there isn’t a kids’ consignment shop nearby, you can still donate your used toys to any thrift store.

Where to sell collectible toys

If you’re looking to sell collectible or vintage toys, these websites are worth checking out:

23. Dylan Universe Comics

Dylan Universe Comics is in the market for your vintage toys and collectibles and is willing to pay top dollar for items such as:

  • Star Wars memorabilia from the 1980s and earlier, including toys, vehicles, and playsets.
  • Action figures from the 1980s and earlier, such as He-Man, GI Joe, and Transformers.
  • Classic monster collectibles from the 1950s and 60s, such as King Kong, Godzilla, Frankenstein, vampires, and more.
  • Vintage toy robots from the 1950s and 60s.
  • Space and sci-fi-related items from the 1970s and earlier.
  • Vintage superhero collectibles, including toys, posters, and costumes.
  • Themed metal lunchboxes.
  • Video games and systems from the 1990s and older, such as Nintendo, Atari, and Gameboy, NES, and more.
  • Sports cards predating 1970, covering baseball, football, hockey, and basketball.
  • Non-Sports Cards predating 1970, such as Batman cards and Wacky Packages.

Even if your items aren’t listed here, Dylan Universe Comics may still be interested. It’s a reliable option to sell your collectible toys for cash.

24. DNR Collectibles

DNR Collectibles buys vintage toys, like:

  • Action figures
  • Model vehicles
  • Barbies
  • Die-cast toys
  • Trains
  • Hess trucks

They offer to pick up your items and pay you cash on the spot for your collection.

25. Toy Origin

If you have pre-owned collectibles that you want to sell, Toy Origin is a great option. The process is simple and hassle-free. First, prepare a list of items you want to sell and take photos of them. This will help Toy Origin evaluate your items and make a fair offer.

After that, use the contact form provided on the Toy Origin website to contact them. Once you submit the form, you can expect a response within 24 to 48 hours. The website will email you back with a quote for your items. The website will email you a prepaid shipping label if you accept the offer.

All you need to do is box up your items and send them to Toy Origin using the prepaid shipping label. The company will then inspect your items to make sure they are in the condition you described. Once the inspection is complete, you will receive payment for your items via PayPal or a certified money order.

It’s that easy, and you can rest assured that Toy Origin is a safe and fair option for selling your collectibles.

26. Etsy

If you’re interested in selling vintage toys online, Etsy is one of the platforms that you should definitely consider. While Etsy is typically associated with handmade and craft items, it also has a fantastic section dedicated to collectibles and vintage items, including toys.

To get started as a seller on Etsy, you’ll have to pay a $0.20 per listing fee. This fee is non-refundable, regardless of whether your item sells. When your item does sell, you will be charged a transaction fee of 5% of the sale price. There is a payment processing fee of 4% plus $0.25 for each transaction.

This fee covers the cost of processing the payment through Etsy’s secure payment system. Given these fees, it’s important to consider your pricing strategy carefully when selling on Etsy and factor in these costs when setting your prices.

27. Comics N Toys

This website lets you sell various collectibles such as toys, action figures, sports cards, comic books, and video games.

Simply contact Comics N Toys by phone or fill out the online form, both available on their website linked above.

The company will appraise your items and provide instant cash offers.

Tips for selling toys

Now, you have numerous options to sell your toys. Here are some helpful tips to ensure your success!

Research your toy’s value

Research their current selling prices to ensure you get the best price for your toys. Check websites like eBay to gauge market value. Investing a little time in this research can help you fetch the highest price for your items.

Be honest about the condition of what you’re selling

It’s tempting to exaggerate the condition of an item when selling it, but it’s not a good idea. Buyers will be disappointed if the condition of the toy doesn’t match the description. This can lead to failed sales or negative reviews, hurting your future sales.

It’s best to be honest about the condition of the toys you’re selling.

Take the time to clean the toys

Many places prefer toys that are both in good condition and clean. Buyers are unlikely to be impressed by stained or dusty items. Therefore, it’s essential to give them a quick clean before putting them up for sale. Clean toys also appear much better in photos, improving their appeal to potential buyers.

Take clear photos

Take photos of the toys in a well-lit area and ensure the background is clear. Avoid uploading blurry pictures at all costs. Sharp, clear photos are essential as potential buyers want to see the item’s appearance before buying.

How to clean used toys before selling

To sell your used kids’ toys and clothes successfully, cleanliness is key. No one wants to purchase stained clothes or teddy bears that have lost their original color.

Plastic toys

Cleaning hard, plastic toys is easy. Use a Lysol wipe or Seventh Generation disinfecting wipes for a plant-based option. After wiping, rinse the toys with water to remove any leftover cleaning products.

Plush toys

For machine-washable plush toys, toss them in the laundry. Put them in a pillowcase and knot them at the top to protect them. If they can’t go in the washing machine, spot clean with soap and water.

Electronic toys

Be cautious with electronic toys. Avoid submerging them in water. Instead, use a damp cloth to remove visible dirt and a disinfecting wipe to finish. Toothpicks and cotton swabs help clean cracks.

Rubber toys

Rubber toys, like bath toys, must be mold-free. Prepare them for sale by using diluted bleach (1:10 bleach to water). Ensure they’re dry inside. If you prefer not to use bleach, try boiling them in water. Remove with tongs and let them air dry completely.

The bottom line

If you have a collection of vintage toys or toys your child doesn’t use anymore, there are many places, both online and offline, where you can sell your toys quickly and easily. Some of these platforms even offer cash payments, and some also allow you to receive your payment through PayPal, making the process even more convenient.

Additionally, if you don’t want to sell your toys, you can always donate them to a good cause. There are many organizations that accept toy donations, so you can feel good knowing that your toys will be put to good use. For more information on where to donate toys, check out our list of the best places to donate.